Document: WM-064                                                 P. Webb
Category: Programming                                         2025.03.04

                        Why I won’t touch React

Abstract

   Outside of my $DAYJOB

Body

   JavaScript frameworks are a dime a dozen and everyone has their
   favorites. HTMX, Solid, Svelte/SvelteKit (my favorite), Next, Remix,
   &c. The industry has long decided on the framework to rule them all,
   React. Which is fine, I guess. Cool.

   My problem is when the industry decides on A Thing™, everyone
   gravitates to this and opposing that can sometimes be difficult.

   Remember "mobile‑first design/development"? This never made sense to
   me. We don’t code on mobile devices, we code on desktop devices…so
   why not start coding for desktop and use media queries to to
   hide/remove elements from mobile views? Being a lowly entry‑level dev
   meant I had no power to push back so it was during this era that I
   decided to apply common sense (to me) coding practices to
   personal projects.

   The industry has since moved on and replaced that practice with
   proper responsive design.

   My reasons for being anti‑React isn’t a knee‑jerk reaction to being a
   "hipster" (anti whatever’s popular), I actually have a few reasons:

   1. My mental model doesn’t mesh with how React works
   2. The way React manages state has always been weird
   3. The internet is rife with outdated/opinionated tutorials

   Keep in mind that I am not up‑to‑date on how React is nowadays so
   maybe my issues with it are expired.

   I’ll contrast the reasons I don’t like React with the reasons I
   like Svelte:

   1. Svelte is the closest to writing vanilla HTML/CSS/JS that I’ve
      found…and I can easily use Sass and TypeScript instead.
   2. Until Svelte 5, managing state in Svelte has been easier for me to
      grok than React. Svelte 5 is quite helpful in their typings when
      you try to mix the old way of managing state with their new way.
   3. I’ve never been confused with Svelte tutorials. It may help that
      Svelte hasn’t had many drastic changes over the years and, being a
      smaller framework means there’s no SEO stuffing or whatever it is
      people do to get more clicks on their ad‑riddled site.

   The last point is rectified these days by a good search engine.
   Google hasn’t been good for quite some time but most people don’t
   care so my last point still stands. Paying for Kagi makes sense for
   me though.

   I will say that React makes sense to use if you have need for React
   Native. From what I understand, React Native is fantastic and comes
   with less headaches than using literally anything else for building
   Android and Apple mobile apps from the same codebase.

   Every "Who’s Hiring" thread on HackerNews is littered with React
   experience of at least a few years. Sometimes a poster will append,
   "or relevant experience" but let’s be real, experience in another
   framework probably doesn’t matter. Job postings on LinkedIn are the
   same but I’d wager HN is better because at least you can contact a
   real person to inquire further.

   This isn’t a bitter blog post btw! I’m more than happy to stubbornly
   wait this phase out just like I did with "mobile‑first design",
   "should designers code?" (designers should absolutely code, it’s
   awesome), and so on. Did you know I was actually chastised for
   spending my lunch breaks as a lowly designer turned developer to read
   up on design trends? Why is what I’m doing bothering YOU?

   Anyhoo, learn React if you gotta (or geniunely want to), I don’t
   care. I’ll be here in 10 years ranting about the next tech industry
   darling that doesn’t make sense to me.

   🕸️